Hello everyone and welcome to a brand new edition of Lil Red’s Book Club! In a spoiler free setting, as always, we will be discussing an eerie horror novel by Josh Malerman called Pictures Of You. I am a big fan of Josh Malerman books so it is always exciting to dive into his unsettling work with something new. Unfortunately, Pictures Of You did not pack as much of a punch as the other books of his that I’ve read and I would definitely call it the weakest of the lot. Although it was a below average read for me, I would still recommend it because I honestly can’t stop thinking about it and that is what Josh Malerman does best. He creates unheard of situations that stick with you regardless of your enjoyment or not. Before we begin, I will be placing a trigger warning on Pictures Of You for general violence and disturbing content. You ready? Let’s get to it:
Emily and Jack are a young couple on a weekend getaway to Wainscott, Michigan. Wainscott is a sleepy lake town where everyone knows everyone and is a perfect spot for a quick trip to enjoy the scenery and have some fun. And, boy, do Jack and Emily have a blast. After exploring the sand dunes and lake, they take to bar hopping for the evening. Knocking back shots, laughing hysterically, and celebrating being young and in love. Sure, there was a strange man that seemed to be following them throughout their night. And, yes, they both couldn’t shake the feeling of someone watching them. But nothing really happens in Wainscott, right?
The following morning, Jack wakes up with a nasty hangover and Emily is nowhere to be found. The following morning, Emily wakes up in an unfamiliar setting. She is in a large bed with clothes on that don’t belong to her and there is a woman studying her closely through an empty picture frame. She wants Emily to lay “just so” and summon an expression of being “loveless”. In her confusion, Emily moves, ruins the picture, and a man from far away begins to scream. Has this mystery woman taken Jack too?
The “artist” insists that Emily will be her finest work yet, and all will be revealed when her masterpiece is complete. In their time together, the artist arranges Emily into new poses with the help of drugs that put her in a stupor. Every time Emily wakes up, she is in new clothing, a new position, and nowhere closer to getting herself out of this impossible situation. It might be the drugs talking, but there is something so familiar about this woman to Emily. And, if she can dig deep into her memories that have long since been forgotten, she just might make it out of here alive. Will Emily escape the artist’s painting? Read Pictures Of You to find out!
Does this book sound weird to you? It should because it was lol! I must say, the premise of an artist “painting” a picture by staring into an empty frame is an intriguing one. Add in a captive woman as the subject and you have got the perfect plot for a chilling horror novel. Sadly, that’s all Pictures Of You was for me. A really interesting idea that never pushed further. The majority of Pictures Of You was Emily being locked in this room with the artist and their encounters, while scary, grew to be very repetitive. It was disappointing because the artist could have been a horrifying villain and that’s what I wanted. Rather, she just read as slightly off her rocker rather than full on insane. What I wanted just wasn’t what this book gave and despite such a gripping plot, it got to the point where it was verging on boring.
Regardless of my lackluster review, I would still recommend Pictures Of You as I mentioned earlier. Simply because I have been mentally going through it with a fine toothed comb since I read the last page. Although Pictures Of You was a slow burn with no real straight answers – I think that was the point. To draw your own conclusions. Me? I like a cut and dry book where the ending ties it up with a pretty little bow. This was not Pictures Of You at all and its vagueness will certainly leave you contemplating it. And, in the end, isn’t that what a good book is supposed to do?
Overall, I am going to rate Pictures Of You with a five out of ten stars. If you like Josh Malerman or straight up weird books, give it a go. If not, you aren’t missing anything if you skip on it!
What is your favorite Josh Malerman book? Who is your favorite horror author that isn’t Stephen King? I want to hear from all of you, so leave me a comment and let’s chat! Much love. -Sarah












